How to Identify the Best Traders to Copy in Copy Trading
EN

Download App

  • Blog Articles   >   Copy Trading

14 July 2025,15:00

Copy TradingHow-toIntermediate

How to Identify the Best Traders to Copy in Copy Trading

14 July 2025, 15:00

Share on:
FacebookLinkedInTwitterShare
Share on:
FacebookLinkedInTwitterShare

The outcome of any copy trading strategy, hinges on one key decision: which traders to copy.

While some traders demonstrate consistency and well-managed risk, others may engage in volatile or unsustainable practices.

Choosing wisely can improve the potential for steady account growth, reduce the likelihood of large drawdowns, and create a more resilient portfolio.

Summary of Key Trader Selection Criteria

CriterionWhat to Look ForWhy It Matters
Track RecordAt least 6–12 months of trading historyShows how the trader performs across different market cycles
Risk ScoreLower or moderate scores, depending on the level of volatility you are prepared to acceptIndicates how aggressively the trader manages their positions
Maximum DrawdownConsistently low drawdownsHelps identify risk exposure during adverse conditions
Consistency of ReturnsSteady gains over time rather than large spikesSuggests a disciplined strategy and reduced volatility
Win RateBalanced with a reward-to-risk ratioHigh win rates alone can be misleading without context
Trade FrequencyAligns with your expectationsDetermines how active the strategy is
TransparencyClear stats and communication (if available)Builds trust and improves decision-making

By understanding what to look for in a trader, investors can make better-informed decisions that align with their financial goals and risk tolerance.

It also helps manage expectations, particularly when trading derivatives such as Contracts for Difference (CFDs), which are speculative instruments that carry the risk of loss and do not involve ownership of the underlying assets.


Why Choosing the Right Trader Matters

The Impact on Investment Outcomes

In copy trading, your performance is directly influenced by the trader you choose to copy.

Their decisions, such as when to enter and exit trades, how much risk to take, and which assets to focus on, all influence your account performance.

A trader with a strong, consistent track record may help deliver more stable results over time, while one with erratic behaviour or excessive leverage may expose your portfolio to increased volatility.

Risk Management Starts with Selection

Selecting the right trader is one of the most effective ways to manage risk in copy trading.

Unlike traditional investing, where risk can be spread across asset classes, copy trading introduces a different layer of dependency based on the trader’s judgement.

Reviewing historical drawdowns, position sizing, and loss-recovery patterns can help avoid unnecessary exposure.

Alignment with Personal Goals

Every trader has a unique approach, whether focused on short-term gains or long-term trends.

Choosing a trader whose strategy matches your financial goals and emotional tolerance for risk can improve the overall experience.

For example, high-risk strategies may suit investors looking for faster gains, while conservative methods may be more appropriate for those seeking consistent, long-term returns.

Key Takeaways

Your portfolio performance reflects the behaviour of the trader you copy.

Trader selection is a key component of risk management in copy trading.

Aligning a trader’s strategy with your financial goals and risk tolerance supports better long-term outcomes.


Exploring The Key Criteria for Selecting Traders



[Source: PU Prime, example of copy traders’ win rate and returns]

Track Record and Trading History

One of the most important indicators of a trader’s reliability is the length and consistency of their track record. Look for traders with at least six months to one year of documented performance.

A longer history allows for better assessment of how they perform in different market conditions, including periods of volatility or drawdown.

Risk Score and Drawdowns

Many platforms assign a risk score based on a trader’s historical behaviour, such as trade size, leverage, and volatility. Lower risk scores typically suggest more stable and conservative strategies, while higher scores may indicate aggressive trading.

Also pay close attention to maximum drawdown figures, which show the largest percentage loss the trader has experienced from peak to trough.

Consistently high drawdowns can be a red flag for poor risk management.

Consistency of Returns

Rather than focusing on short bursts of high profits, evaluate whether a trader delivers consistent monthly or quarterly returns.

This consistency often reflects disciplined strategy execution and better risk control.

Sudden spikes in profit can sometimes indicate risky behaviour that may not be sustainable.

Win Rate and Trade Frequency

A high win rate can be appealing, but it should be evaluated in context. For instance, a trader with a high win rate and small profits per trade may still suffer large losses if unsuccessful trades are poorly managed.

Also consider how frequently they trade, as some traders may place multiple trades a day, while others take fewer, longer-term positions.

Align this with your own expectations and preferences.

Communication and Transparency

Some platforms allow traders to share commentary or strategy notes. Traders who communicate openly about their approach, strategy adjustments, or market outlook demonstrate greater transparency.

While not always available, this level of detail can support more informed decision-making.

Key Takeaways

Look for traders with a long and consistent performance history. Review risk scores and drawdowns to understand exposure levels.

Prioritise consistency of returns over short-term profit spikes. Evaluate win rate and trading frequency in the context of strategy. Transparency and communication, where available, are valuable indicators of professionalism.


Common Trading Styles

Traders use a range of strategies based on market conditions, technical or fundamental analysis, and time commitment. Below is a summary of common styles and their key characteristics:

Trading StyleTypical Trade DurationRisk ProfileDescription
ScalpingSeconds to minutesHighHigh-frequency trading targeting very small price movements.
Day TradingWithin the same dayModerate to HighIntraday trading with no overnight positions.
Swing TradingDays to weeksModerateCaptures medium-term trends using technical/fundamental cues.
Position TradingWeeks to monthsLow to ModerateLong-term strategy based on macro trends and fundamentals.

Matching Style to Risk Tolerance

Scalping and day trading require high attention and involve rapid decision-making. These styles may result in frequent gains and losses, making them more volatile.

In contrast, swing and position trading involve fewer trades and are generally more stable, potentially suiting those with lower risk tolerance or limited time.

Selecting a trader whose approach aligns with your financial goals and emotional comfort level helps improve confidence during market fluctuations.

Key Takeaways

Different trading styles vary in duration, volatility, and strategic focus. Use the trader’s profile and history to assess their typical trading style.

Choose a style that suits your risk tolerance and involvement preference. A well-aligned trading style supports a more consistent and comfortable experience.


Warning Signs of High-Risk Traders

  • Excessive or Unstable Drawdowns

A trader who frequently experiences large or erratic drawdowns may be using poor risk management or relying on high-risk strategies. Even if past performance looks strong overall, deep losses during short periods can indicate instability that may not align with a long-term investment approach.

  • Unrealistic Performance Spikes

Sudden, sharp gains in a trader’s performance history may appear attractive, but they can also be signs of overleveraging or unsustainable tactics. A rapid rise in returns without a clear explanation often precedes sharp reversals. Long-term consistency is a more reliable indicator than short-term outperformance.

  • Lack of Transparency

A trader who provides limited data on their strategy, trading history, or risk metrics can make evaluation difficult. Platforms that allow trader commentary or strategy outlines offer greater transparency. If this information is unavailable or vague, it may be best to proceed with caution.

  • High Trade Volume with Poor Results

Some traders open and close many trades in quick succession without delivering meaningful returns. High trade volume without corresponding profitability can indicate a lack of strategic planning or attempts to mask underperformance through activity.

  • Recent Shifts in Strategy

Changes in trade frequency, asset class focus, or risk exposure may signal a departure from the trader’s previous approach.

While strategy evolution is normal, abrupt and unexplained shifts may reduce predictability and increase risk.

  • Overly Aggressive Leverage

Leverage can amplify returns but also increases the potential for losses. Traders who consistently use high levels of leverage may achieve impressive gains in favourable conditions, but they are also more vulnerable to large losses during market downturns.

Leverage levels are often disclosed on the platform, allowing users to factor this into their evaluation.

Key Takeaways

Large or erratic drawdowns may reflect poor risk control. Sudden gains can indicate unsustainable trading practices.

Transparency in data and strategy supports better decision-making. Frequent, unprofitable trading may signal weak strategy. Monitor for abrupt changes in behaviour or excessive use of leverage.


Diversification and Multiple Traders

Why Diversification Matters in Copy Trading

Just as with traditional investing, diversification in copy trading helps reduce reliance on a single strategy or market outcome.

Relying solely on one trader introduces concentration risk. If that trader underperforms or alters their approach, your entire portfolio could be affected.

Diversifying across multiple traders can smooth returns and reduce overall volatility.

Benefits of Copying Multiple Traders

By following traders with different styles, asset focuses, and risk levels, you can create a more balanced portfolio.

For example, one trader may specialise in forex scalping while another takes longer-term positions in indices.

Combining these profiles can help capture different market opportunities while managing downside risk.

Managing Allocation Across Traders

It is important to consider how much capital you assign to each trader. Allocating equal amounts is one approach, but some users prefer to weigh their investments based on a trader’s risk score, consistency, or performance history.

Most platforms, including PU Prime, allow flexible allocation settings so you can manage exposure according to your preferences.

Avoiding Overdiversification

While diversification is valuable, following too many traders can dilute results and make performance monitoring more difficult.

Aim to strike a balance between spreading risk and maintaining clarity over how your account is performing.

Key Takeaways

Diversifying across multiple traders reduces reliance on a single strategy. Combining different trading styles can help manage risk and improve balance.

Allocate funds strategically based on trader performance and risk profile.

Avoid overdiversification by limiting the number of traders you copy to a manageable level.


Platform Features to Consider

Transparent Performance Metrics

A reliable copy trading platform should provide clear, detailed information on each trader’s history.

Look for features that display return rates over time, maximum drawdowns, win rates, and asset allocation.

This transparency enables you to evaluate traders objectively and align them with your risk tolerance and goals.

Risk Management Tools

Built-in tools for setting risk parameters can offer additional control over your portfolio. These include options such as setting maximum loss limits, applying equity stop-outs, or choosing how much of your capital to allocate per trader.

Platforms that offer this level of customisation help users actively manage risk.

Control Over Copied Trades

Some platforms allow you to adjust or stop copying a trader at any time.

This flexibility can be important when market conditions change or if a trader begins to underperform.

Being able to pause or exit without penalty ensures you retain control over your investments.

Fee Structures and Costs

Understanding how fees are charged is essential. Some platforms operate on a commission basis, while others may deduct a percentage of profits or use performance-based models.

PU Prime offers competitive pricing with no hidden charges, making it easier to track overall returns. Users should review the platform’s fee disclosure page or terms before making investment decisions.

Trader Profiles and Communication

Although not always available, some traders provide commentary on their strategy or market view.

When accessible, this can offer valuable insight into their thinking and help you build confidence in their decision-making.

Profiles that include strategy descriptions, trade frequency, and asset preferences provide a more complete picture of the trader.

Key Takeaways

Choose platforms that offer full visibility into trader performance and statistics. Risk management tools help tailor your exposure and protect capital.

Retaining control over copied trades supports flexible decision-making. Understand how fees are applied to evaluate cost-effectiveness.

Detailed trader profiles improve decision quality and transparency.


How to Start Copy Trading

  • Step 1: Choose a Regulated Platform

Begin by selecting a reputable and regulated copy trading platform. PU Prime offers access to a wide range of traders, along with performance data and customisable risk settings. Choosing a regulated provider helps ensure a secure trading environment and greater transparency.

  • Step 2: Open and Fund Your Account

Registering an account typically involves identity verification and basic financial information. Once your account is approved, you can deposit funds using one of the available payment methods. Be sure to check the platform’s minimum deposit requirement before getting started.

  • Step 3: Explore Trader Profiles

Browse through available traders using filters such as return rates, drawdown levels, trading styles, or risk scores. Take time to review historical performance data, trading activity, and profile details. Look for consistency, clear strategy descriptions, and alignment with your investment preferences.

  • Step 4: Allocate Funds and Set Risk Parameters

After selecting a trader, choose how much of your capital you want to allocate.

Many platforms allow users to set custom limits, such as a maximum loss amount or percentage allocation per trader. Setting these parameters provides a safety net in the event of unexpected market movements.

  • Step 5: Start Copying and Monitor Progress

Once setup is complete, the platform will begin copying trades automatically. From here, you can monitor your account balance, performance metrics, and trading activity through your dashboard.

Some users may choose to copy multiple traders, while others start with one and expand later.

Key Takeaways

Select a regulated copy trading platform to ensure safety and access to performance data. Fund your account and explore trader profiles based on key metrics. Allocate capital carefully and use available tools to manage risk. Monitor your copied trades regularly and adjust settings as needed.


Monitoring and Adjusting Your Copy Portfolio

Why Ongoing Monitoring Is Essential

Copy trading is not a fully passive strategy. While trades are executed automatically, regular monitoring helps ensure that the traders you follow remain aligned with your expectations.

Market conditions can change, and a trader’s behaviour may shift over time.

Checking in periodically allows you to respond to these developments in a timely manner.

What to Watch For

Key areas to review include changes in a trader’s drawdown level, win rate, trade frequency, and asset focus.

Unexpected shifts in strategy or performance could signal increased risk or reduced consistency.

A steady increase in drawdowns or a pattern of unprofitable trades may warrant closer attention.

When to Make Adjustments

You may choose to stop copying a trader if their strategy no longer suits your goals, or if their risk exposure increases beyond your comfort level.

Most platforms, including PU Prime, allow you to pause or exit copy trading relationships at any time.

You can also reallocate capital to other traders to improve diversification or rebalance based on performance.

Maintaining a Disciplined Approach

Avoid making changes based solely on short-term results or emotional reactions to market movements.

A trader may experience short periods of underperformance as part of a broader, long-term strategy.

Reviewing data over a reasonable timeframe can help you make more informed decisions.

Key Takeaways

Regular monitoring supports better control and long-term portfolio alignment.

Track trader behaviour for signs of increased risk or strategy changes.

Adjust or stop copying as needed using platform controls. Maintain a balanced, data-driven approach rather than reacting to short-term fluctuations.


Learning from Copied Trades

Copy Trading as a Learning Tool

In addition to potential returns, copy trading can provide valuable insights into market strategies and trader behaviour.

Observing how experienced traders react to different market conditions helps build a deeper understanding of technical analysis, risk management, and trading psychology.

Identifying Patterns and Strategy Elements

By reviewing the entry and exit points, asset choices, and trade durations of the traders you follow, you can begin to recognise patterns and decision-making frameworks.

Over time, this observation may support your own confidence in interpreting market movements or understanding why certain trades are executed.

Enhancing Market Awareness

Copy trading allows you to stay engaged with the financial markets even without actively placing trades.

Exposure to different trading styles and asset classes broadens your awareness of how markets operate and respond to global events.

Key Takeaways

Copy trading offers an opportunity to observe real-world trading strategies. Watching trader behaviour can build knowledge of market dynamics.

Increased exposure supports better long-term understanding, even without active participation.


Make Smarter Copy Trading Decisions

Success in copy trading depends on more than following high return figures.

It requires selecting traders whose behaviour aligns with your goals, monitoring performance regularly, and staying informed about the strategies being applied on your behalf.

By applying thoughtful criteria, using available platform features, and diversifying wisely, you can reduce unnecessary exposure to risk and improve your long-term trading experience.

While copy trading offers accessibility, it still involves risk. Trading Contracts for Difference (CFDs) means speculating on price movements without owning the underlying assets.

Understanding the tools and data available is essential to managing that risk effectively.

Tips for Traders

  • Choose traders with consistent, long-term performance data
  • Prioritise transparency and clear trading history
  • Use risk management tools to protect capital
  • Diversify across multiple strategies to smooth volatility
  • Monitor performance and be ready to make adjustments

To begin, you’ll need to open a live trading account.

Get started with copy trading directly on PU Prime.


FAQ

What are the best traders to copy?
The best traders to copy are those with a consistent track record, low to moderate drawdowns, transparent strategies, and risk levels that match your investment preferences.

Look for profiles with detailed performance data and trading history available on regulated platforms like PU Prime.

Is copy trading suitable for beginners?
Yes, copy trading is often used by beginners as it allows them to access financial markets without placing trades manually.

However, it still involves risk, and it’s important to understand how the platform and trading strategies work before committing real capital.

Can I lose money with copy trading?
Yes, losses are possible. Since copy trading typically involves CFDs, your account is subject to the performance and risk profile of the trader you copy.

Losses may occur if market conditions change or if the trader’s strategy underperforms.

How many traders should I copy at once?
There is no fixed number, but copying multiple traders can help spread risk.

Aim for a manageable number based on your capital, goals, and ability to monitor performance.

Avoid overdiversification, which can make performance tracking difficult.

Can I stop copying a trader at any time?
Most platforms, including PU Prime, allow you to stop or pause copy trading at any point.

This gives you control over your portfolio and helps you respond to changes in trader behaviour or market conditions.

How much do I need to start copy trading?
Minimum investment requirements vary by platform. PU Prime offers flexible options with low entry points, allowing users to start with amounts suited to their individual preferences.

Start trading with an edge today

Trade forex, indices, metal, and more at industry-low spreads and lightning-fast execution.

  • Start trading with deposits as low as $50 on our standard accounts.
  • Get access to 24/7 support.
  • Access hundreds of instruments, free educational tools, and some of the best promotions around.
Join Now

Latest Posts

Fast And Easy Account Opening

Create account
  • 1

    Register

    Sign up for a PU Prime Live Account with our hassle-free process.

  • 2

    Fund

    Effortlessly fund your account with a wide range of channels and accepted currencies.

  • 3

    Start Trading

    Access hundreds of instruments under market-leading trading conditions.

Please note the Website is intended for individuals residing in jurisdictions where accessing the Website is permitted by law.

Please note that PU Prime and its affiliated entities are neither established nor operating in your home jurisdiction.

By clicking the "Acknowledge" button, you confirm that you are entering this website solely based on your initiative and not as a result of any specific marketing outreach. You wish to obtain information from this website which is provided on reverse solicitation in accordance with the laws of your home jurisdiction.

Thank You for Your Acknowledgement!

Ten en cuenta que el sitio web está destinado a personas que residen en jurisdicciones donde el acceso al sitio web está permitido por la ley.

Ten en cuenta que PU Prime y sus entidades afiliadas no están establecidas ni operan en tu jurisdicción de origen.

Al hacer clic en el botón "Aceptar", confirmas que estás ingresando a este sitio web por tu propia iniciativa y no como resultado de ningún esfuerzo de marketing específico. Deseas obtener información de este sitio web que se proporciona mediante solicitud inversa de acuerdo con las leyes de tu jurisdicción de origen.

Thank You for Your Acknowledgement!